Disclosure: OneHourProfessor is reader-supported. When you buy through links on my site, I may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Email marketing can be a powerful tool for insurance agents looking to grow their business. With the right strategy, email allows you to nurture relationships, cross-sell products, upsell policies, and retain more clients. 

In this article, we provide 11 proven tips to help insurance agents get the most out of their email campaigns. 

By following these simple but effective tactics, you’ll be on the path to expanding your reach, boosting conversions, and increasing sales. Whether you’re just starting with emails or looking to improve existing efforts, these guidelines will help you 4x your insurance business.

Why Should Insurance Agents Use Email Marketing? 

Email marketing software is a must for insurance agents looking to grow their book of business. Studies show that email generates $42 for every $1 spent, delivering the highest ROI of any marketing channel. 

Beyond increased revenue, a strategic email program provides numerous core benefits that directly support insurance sales goals. 

Email allows agents to strengthen client relationships through consistent, valuable communications. It enables upselling and cross-selling by matching policyholders with relevant offerings. Email helps retain more customers by keeping your brand top of your mind. Targeted campaigns can also reactivate lapsed customers. 

Customer-friendly messaging generates more referrals. Helpful, non-promotional content builds trust and credibility. 

With the ability to segment contacts, tailor messaging, automate workflows, and analyze performance, email gives agents a customizable platform to deepen engagement and drive measurable growth. Adopting email best practices pays dividends across all aspects of an agency’s operations.

1. Build a Targeted Email List

A quality email list is the foundation of every successful email marketing program. Too often, insurance agents take the quick route of buying generic lists or scraping contact info from the web. This delivers poor results and jeopardizes deliverability. For optimal ROI, agents should focus on building a targeted list from their existing customers and connections.

Start gathering emails by adding signup forms and Calls-To-Action (CTAs) across all touchpoints, including your website, blog, social accounts, promotional materials, and client meetings. 

Specifically, ask satisfied policyholders to share your agency’s emails with family and friends who may need coverage. Many will happily refer others if it provides value rather than a sales pitch. 

Gradually grow your list with potential customers who have organically expressed interest. You want engaged subscribers truly interested in your offerings, not cold contacts wary of unsolicited messages.

Segment this list by client type, policy type, demographics, location, communication preferences, and other relevant factors that allow you to tailor content. Personalized email drives 6 times higher transaction rates. 

Laser-focused messaging also helps upsell and cross-sell more accurately. Invest the effort in quality over quantity when building your email list for maximum long-term payoff.

2. Craft Attention-Grabbing Subject Lines

Your subject line is the first and possibly only thing subscribers see in their inbox. With over 120 business emails received daily, breaking through the noise is vital. 

The average open rate for insurance emails falls between 20-30%, highlighting the need for compelling headlines tailored to each segment. Mastering this makes or breaks campaign performance.

Focus on creating subscriber-centric subject lines that instantly communicate value and relevance. What do they care most about? 

  • Highlight savings opportunities, safety recommendations, ways to lower risk, or peace of mind against uncertainties. 
  • Speak to their self-interest while framing your offerings as the solution. 
  • Use emotional triggers, thought-provoking questions, curiosity gaps, and personalized information to grab attention while building brand affinity over time through consistency. 
  • Test different subject line formulations, lengths, and calls to action across customer groups to determine what resonates best. 

The extra effort taken to understand motivations and craft targeted subject lines directly translates to higher open and click-through rates.

3. Personalize Your Emails

Generic “one-size-fits-all” emails fail to make meaningful connections with subscribers. Personalized messaging helps your emails seem like an individual conversation instead of a sales pitch. 

With each policyholder having unique needs and priorities, tailoring content accordingly leads to 6X higher transaction rates.

You need an intimate understanding of your best customer types. Develop hyper-specific personas based on distinct customer attributes, such as “retired couple in Miami concerned about hurricane damage coverage” or “Seattle tech employees wanting high-limit renters insurance.” Segment your list by location, policy types, demographics, interests, and any other relevant factor accordingly.

  • Map specific offerings and messaging to each group based on what matters most to them. 
  • Personalize subject lines using merge tags to include their name, city, or policy details. 
  • Reference prior conversations and use behavioral data to match them with appropriate cross-sells. 

The more relevance and customization injected into each email, the higher engagement and conversion you’ll achieve. Avoid impersonal batch-and-blast campaigns in favor of strategic personalization at scale.

4. Design Professional and Informative Emails

Email design plays a crucial role in engagement, click-throughs, and overall campaign success. Unfortunately, many insurance agents overlook presentations in favor of cramming emails full of promotions and offers. This overwhelms subscribers, hurting open and conversion rates. Instead, focus on clean, professional templates and informative content they want to consume.

  • Stick to simple single-column layouts that prominently feature important text and images at the top. 
  • Use whitespace wisely – don’t overcrowd the design. 
  • Make key calls to action obvious through size, color, and strategic placement. 
  • Write smooth transitions between sections and chunks of content for better flow. 

Showcase helpful tips, educational resources, and human interest stories more prominently over direct product pitches. Guide subscribers through emails with clear internal navigation. Fine-tune formatting until content is crisp and appealing. 

Do your best to keep to the ideal email length, which according to a recent study is between 150 – 200 words. 


A polished, readable template that quickly communicates value establishes trust and credibility with subscribers faster for a more receptive selling environment.

5. Stick to a Consistent Communication Schedule

Gaining mindshare and driving conversions requires consistency in messaging. Yet many insurance agents email sporadically whenever it’s convenient or they have an urgent promotion. This scattershot approach frustrates subscribers, trains them to ignore communications, and suppresses response over time. Delivering predictable value cultivates trust faster.

Establish a structured email calendar that routinizes critical customer touchpoints around renewals, quarterly check-ins, seasonal policy reviews, risk management tips, etc. Integrate sequences to onboard new policyholders and reactivate dormant ones. 

Develop a library of evergreen content and helpful resources to mix into scheduled campaigns that demonstrate ongoing helpfulness outside of selling. 

The software enables easy automation while still personalizing parts of messages. The reliability of on-time, subscriber-focused emails builds brand affinity and openness to recommendations better over an inconsistent, promotion-heavy approach. Think long-term nurturing over short-term sales.

6. Segment Your Email List

One of the biggest email marketing mistakes is failing to properly segment your list. Sending the same message to all contacts misses opportunities to hyper-target different customer groups. 

This overlooks their unique situations and insurance needs for lower engagement. Matching specific policy types and coverages to the right audiences is key.

Subdivide your list based on meaningful attributes like location, existing policies, demographics, interests, and buying stage. Develop custom messaging and product recommendations tailored to each group’s concerns or knowledge gaps. Further, personalize using cross-channel data like web-behavior. 

Testing shows smaller segmented lists drive higher performance over general blasts. Someone recently married will receive an entirely different email than empty nest retirees reevaluating policies. 

New homeowners have different information needs than longtime renters. Get granular with segmentation for superior deliverability, open rates, and more policy sales conveying you understand their world.

7. Provide Value-Driven Content

Insurance can be a complex, dry subject matter. That’s why solely promoting products falls flat – it’s inherently boring to most people. Emails overflowing with sales text also train subscribers to tune them out. 

The best email marketing strategy involves shifting the focus toward value-driven content addressing actual concerns, fears, and problems to demonstrate your agency’s ongoing helpfulness between policy sales.

Determine pressing issues separate customer groups face and provide answers through informational content about navigating risks. 

  • What loss scenarios keep them awake? 
  • Where do they have coverage gaps? 

Develop subscriber-centered emails delivering tips, best practices, and resources aligned to current challenges. You can weave in properly positioned product recommendations as needed solutions, not the priority. 


Driving open and click rates through non-promotional education, lifestyle management, and industry guidance establishes authority. 

Subscribers consume and share helpful emails, laying social proof foundations that earn new business referrals. Give before asking to get.

8. Use Clear Calls-to-Action (CTAs)

Calls-to-action can turn awareness into action by clearly telling subscribers their next step. Without them, even the most compelling email only impresses instead of incites a response. 

Overlooking CTAs leaves money on the table. Yet most insurance emails expect readers to spontaneously know the desired behavior. Be more direct.

You need to strategically insert clickable CTAs at the top, middle, and bottom of emails when relevant to increase visibility. This gives readers multiple opportunities to convert. Use action-oriented language like “Get Your Quote” or “See Options” – tell them what button to click. 

Design CTAs to contrast surrounding text through size, color, and placement, emphasizing their importance.

Avoid generic phrases like “Learn More” which confuse more than convert. Link CTAs directly to targeted landing pages with personalized product suggestions, quote generators, and application forms for a seamless user experience. 

Removing friction and signaling intent lifts conversion rates substantially. Carefully crafted CTAs tell readers the immediate action you want them to take next.

9. Embrace Automation for Efficiency

Implementing email automation elevates results by increasing campaign volume, freeing up time, and enabling advanced personalization. 

Despite the benefits, many insurance agents hesitate to set up workflows that facilitate repetitive tasks. However robust platforms make it simple to automate various customer trigger scenarios.

Begin by mapping common situations like new policy purchases, renewal reminders, and customer win-backs. Configure sequences addressing each milestone with relevant information and offers. Build segmentation and conditional logic to deliver hyper-targeted messaging matching specific policyholder data and behaviors. 

Testing shows automated flows lift engagement over 2X manual efforts alone. And they operate 24/7 with little ongoing management once created. 

For underutilized agencies, embrace automation to communicate consistently at scale on autopilot for bigger sales wins. The technology is available to emulate real-time email personalization powered by intelligent automation.

10. Monitor and Analyze Performance Metrics

The only way to maximize email ROI is by carefully monitoring campaign analytics to uncover optimization opportunities. Yet with busy sales schedules, few insurance agents spend time digging into their program’s health. 

This blinds them from refinements that inch open, click, and conversion rates higher. Dedicate time to properly gauge effectiveness.

Analyze email metrics like deliverability, open, click-through, and conversion rates on both campaign and list levels. 

Review historical performance to detect trends positive and negative. Dig deeper into specific segments to identify higher and lower response groups crucial for appropriate messaging and creative decisions. 

Let data guide editing, not assumptions. Enable read receipt notifications to monitor real-time reactions. Also, check industry standards like the ones in the example below to see where your business falls. 


Continually test new subject lines, content formats, and designs against each other. Pay attention to what metrics indicate is resonating best with whom. Keep a pulse on email effectiveness through habitual analytics checks that precipitate incremental performance gains over taking effectiveness for granted.

11. Use Surveys for Feedback

The best way to improve email relevancy and engagement is by surveying subscribers directly. Yet rarely do insurance agents ask contacts for opinions on their communications. This squanders free access to field intelligence other data can’t provide. Use surveys to collect customer insights faster.

Occasionally poll email list members requesting input on content interests, preferred frequencies, features to add or remove, and general thoughts. This qualitative feedback exposes blindspots to guide program adjustments increasing satisfaction. 

Additionally, insert post-campaign surveys into recent email sequences gauging what messages and offers resonated best and why. Drill down with probes on subject line preferences, design comments, and reasons for not clicking. 

Zero in on trouble areas emails unambiguously revealed through pointed survey questions. The voice of your customers identifies refinements statistically impossible to pinpoint otherwise. Maintain an open dialogue with readers; campaigns should evolve based on collaborative survey learnings instead of just your perceived notions of effectiveness.

Email marketing presents a tremendous growth opportunity for insurance agents to cost-effectively nurture relationships, retain more customers, and drive referrals. By following the 11 tips outlined, agents can create segmented lists, craft compelling content, personalize messaging, automate workflows, and analyze performance. 

This structured approach to email strategy maximizes open, click, and conversion rates for multiplying policy sales. 

Dedicating time to send consistent, valuable communications pays dividends across every KPI. Now is the time for agents to step up their email game to generate more prospects and dramatically expand their book of business.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}